INTRODUCTION
At the incorporation stage of joint-stock companies, assets contributed as capital in kind are valued by court-appointed experts, thereby ensuring that the company’s capital is backed by assets of real value. However, this protective mechanism may be circumvented by incorporating the company with cash capital and subsequently transferring assets belonging to founders or third parties to the company for a consideration exceeding their actual value.
To prevent this risk, Article 356 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (“TCC“), entitled “Circumvention of the Law“, sets out the provision referred to in legal scholarship and practice as “post-incorporation acquisition“. Under the first paragraph of the article, agreements for the acquisition or leasing of an enterprise or an asset in kind, concluded within two years of the company’s registration with the trade registry for a consideration exceeding one-tenth of its share capital, are invalid unless approved by the general assembly and registered with the trade registry. Under the same paragraph, any disposition made in performance of such agreements before their approval and registration, including payments, is also deemed invalid.
WHICH TRANSACTIONS ARE SUBJECT TO THE POST-INCORPORATION ACQUISITION PROVISION?
Article 356(1) of the TCC regulates post-incorporation acquisition and lease transactions within a specific scope in terms of duration, subject matter and consideration. The following factors are taken into account in determining the scope of application of the provision:
- The agreement for the post-incorporation acquisition or lease must be concluded within two years of the company’s registration with the trade registry. The decisive factor is the date on which the agreement is concluded; the fact that performance, general assembly approval or registration falls outside the two-year period does not change this outcome. This provision of the TCC is mandatory, and it is accepted that the period cannot be modified by the articles of association.
- The subject matter of the post-incorporation acquisition or lease agreement must be an enterprise or an asset in kind. The concept of an “asset in kind” is interpreted broadly in legal scholarship and is understood to include assets that may be contributed as capital in kind under Articles 127 and 342 of the TCC, such as movable and immovable property, intellectual property rights and shares in other companies.
- The acquisition or lease consideration must exceed one-tenth of the company’s share capital. It is important to note, however, that where a single transaction is divided into several legal transactions in order to remain below the one-tenth threshold, it is accepted that agreements forming an economic whole must be treated as a single legal transaction.
In calculating the one-tenth threshold, the share capital on the date of the agreement is taken as the basis, while in joint-stock companies under the registered capital system, the issued capital is used instead. If the capital was increased or decreased before the agreement, the capital after the change is taken into account. For lease agreements, legal scholarship holds that either the entire prepaid amount or the total amount payable over the fixed term of the agreement should be taken as the basis. For leases of indefinite duration, however, the view that the amount should be calculated by reference to the first termination notice period is criticized on the grounds that it could lead to circumvention of the provision.
The provision does not impose any restriction on who the counterparty may be; it covers agreements concluded with founders, shareholders and third parties. Where the counterparty is a shareholder, that shareholder cannot vote on the general assembly resolution approving the agreement pursuant to Article 436(1) of the TCC.
Nevertheless, under Article 356(5) of the TCC, the provision does not apply to assets in kind and enterprises that form the subject matter of the company’s business or are acquired through compulsory enforcement. In legal scholarship, the business subject-matter exception is interpreted as being limited to current assets, such as raw materials, which the company regularly acquires in the ordinary course of its business; fixed assets, such as factories, machinery or business premises, are understood to remain within the scope of the provision.
WHAT ARE THE CONSEQUENCES OF NON-COMPLIANCE WITH THE PROVISION?
For a post-incorporation acquisition or lease agreement falling within Article 356(1) of the TCC to be valid, both general assembly approval and registration with the trade registry are required. Under Article 356(2) of the TCC, before the transaction is submitted for general assembly approval, the enterprises and assets in kind to be acquired or leased must be valued by an expert appointed, at the request of the board of directors, by the Commercial Court of First Instance at the place where the company’s registered office is located. By virtue of the cross-reference in Article 356(3), Article 421(3) and (4) of the TCC applies: the approval resolution must be adopted by the affirmative votes of the holders, or their representatives, of shares representing at least 75% of the company’s share capital. If this quorum is not reached at the first meeting, the same quorum is required at subsequent meetings.
Therefore, the agreement does not become valid until the requirements of valuation, general assembly approval and registration are fulfilled. The TCC also explicitly declares invalid any disposition made to perform the agreement. As a result, payments made before approval and registration are invalid. Similarly, the delivery of a movable asset under the agreement does not transfer ownership, and the registration of an immovable property in the company’s name at the land registry constitutes an unlawful registration (yolsuz tescil).
Regarding the nature of the invalidity, the prevailing view in legal scholarship is that the agreement remains in a state of suspended invalidity until general assembly approval and registration with the trade registry have been completed. According to this view, the agreement is not binding on the company during the suspension period, whereas the counterparty remains bound by it. However, if general assembly approval is not granted within a reasonable period, the counterparty may give notice that it is no longer bound by the agreement. The agreement becomes valid upon completion of the required procedures. By contrast, if the general assembly fails to approve the agreement with the required majority, the state of suspended invalidity ends and the agreement becomes definitively null and void. This situation must be assessed separately from a case in which the approval and registration procedures have merely not yet been completed.
It is important to note that the expiry of the two-year period does not, of itself, render valid an agreement concluded in breach of Article 356 of the TCC. Nor can the board of directors render the agreement valid by relying on its authority to represent the company. Furthermore, the consequences of non-compliance are not limited to the invalidity of the agreement: members of the board of directors may also incur liability under Article 553 of the TCC if they culpably breach their statutory duties and thereby cause damage.
WHAT ARE THE VALIDITY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE TRANSACTION?
For acquisition or lease agreements within the scope of Article 356 of the TCC to become valid, the valuation, general assembly approval and trade registry registration procedures prescribed by law must be completed. The following steps are required, in this order:
- Valuation of the enterprise or asset in kind acquired or leased by an expert appointed, at the request of the board of directors, by the Commercial Court of First Instance at the place where the company’s registered office is located;
- Submission of the expert report to the general assembly and approval of the transaction by the affirmative votes of the holders, or their representatives, of shares representing at least 75% of the share capital; and
- Registration and announcement of the agreement with the trade registry, together with the general assembly’s approval resolution (TCC Art. 356(4)).
Although there is an announcement obligation, the announcement is not a condition for the validity of the agreement. General assembly approval does not have to be obtained before the agreement is concluded and may also be granted afterwards. Therefore, the agreement may still become valid if the procedures prescribed under the TCC are fully completed at a later stage.
CONCLUSION
Article 356(1) of the TCC establishes a protective mechanism intended to prevent the rules governing the valuation of capital in kind at the incorporation of joint-stock companies from being circumvented through post-incorporation acquisition and lease transactions. Accordingly, the validity of acquisition and lease agreements concluded within two years of the company’s registration with the trade registry for a consideration exceeding one-tenth of its share capital is subject to an expert valuation, a general assembly approval resolution adopted by a qualified majority and registration with the trade registry. Until these requirements have been fulfilled, the agreements and any dispositions made in their performance are deemed invalid.
Nevertheless, legal scholarship accepts that the initial deficiency may be remedied if the procedures prescribed by law are completed later.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is a post-incorporation acquisition? It is the acquisition or leasing of an enterprise or an asset in kind by a joint-stock company within two years of its registration with the trade registry for a consideration exceeding one-tenth of its share capital. Such agreements are invalid unless approved by the general assembly and registered with the trade registry.
- How is the two-year period calculated? The period starts on the date the company is registered with the trade registry. The decisive factor is the date on which the agreement is concluded; the fact that performance, general assembly approval or registration takes place after this period does not change the outcome.
- What quorum is required for general assembly approval? The affirmative votes of the holders of shares representing at least 75% of the share capital, or their representatives, are required. The same quorum also applies at subsequent meetings. Before the approval resolution is adopted, the assets must be valued by a court-appointed expert.
- Does the expiry of the two-year period validate the agreement? No. An agreement concluded in breach of Article 356 of the TCC does not automatically become valid when the two-year period expires.
- Can an agreement concluded without approval be validated later? Yes. General assembly approval may also be granted after the agreement is concluded. The agreement becomes valid once the expert valuation is carried out, general assembly approval is obtained and the agreement is registered and announced together with the approval resolution.










